Roll Call TrackMembersBills & VotesBreaking NewsDisclosures

Explainer

Alaska’s Two-Sullivan Senate Race: DOJ Suit Dismissed, Election Still Uncalled

Judge Gleason dismissed DOJ’s Alaska ballot lawsuit Nov. 1; DOJ appealed. The Senate race remains uncalled, with preliminary first-choice counts and ranked-choice results still pending.

Latest — Nov. 6, 2026: Judge Sharon L. Gleason dismissed the Justice Department’s civil lawsuit on Nov. 1. She did not order ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. segregated or certification delayed. DOJ appealed. Alaska’s Senate election remained uncalled in the reporting reviewed Friday: Mary Peltola had 102,962 first-choice votes, incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan had 102,325, and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. had 3,600. These are preliminary counts, not final rankings or certified results. Alaska says official ranked-choice results will not be available until Nov. 18. A separate criminal investigation has continued. 13

Election Day has passed, but Alaska has not finished choosing its next U.S. senator. The two candidates with similar names remain different people, with separate votes and separate federal campaign records. Neither the dismissal of the lawsuit nor either campaign’s claim about its prospects determines the election’s winner.

What Judge Gleason decided

In United States v. State of Alaska, No. 3:26-cv-00376-SLG, Gleason granted dismissal motions from Alaska and intervenors on Nov. 1. The federal government had sought to hold up certification if the incumbent lost and investigate whether confusion with the other Sullivan affected the outcome. Its later request included separating ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan. 1

The problem was Article III standing: DOJ had not shown how the relief it sought could remedy its alleged injury. Gleason wrote that the United States had “failed to establish the redressability prerequisite for Article III standing.” She emphasized the absence of a workable explanation for investigating voters’ intentions while protecting ballot secrecy. 1 (pp. 10–18)

In plain English, Alaska and the intervenors won dismissal in the district court. DOJ did not obtain the injunction it wanted. The amended complaint was dismissed without prejudice, but Gleason denied leave to amend it again in this case; the preliminary-injunction and related expedition requests were denied as moot. That is a jurisdictional ruling, not a verdict that anyone committed a crime, and not a decision awarding the Senate seat. 1 (pp. 18–20)

DOJ appealed; dismissal is not the entire story

DOJ filed a notice of appeal on Nov. 1. The public docket reproduced by the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse identifies Ninth Circuit case 26-7304. Its listed schedule calls for DOJ’s opening brief on Dec. 14 and the answering brief on Jan. 11, 2027. Anchorage Daily News independently reported that schedule on Nov. 5. 2

No later order reversing the dismissal or granting ballot-segregation relief was identified in the public materials reviewed through Nov. 6. That is a dated reporting check, not a claim that the appeal has ended. The district-court dismissal should not be described as an unappealable final resolution of every dispute.

What the election count shows

Anchorage Daily News and Alaska’s News Source reported these preliminary first-choice figures, from results last updated Wednesday: 2

Candidate Preliminary first-choice votes
Mary Peltola 102,962
Dan S. Sullivan, incumbent 102,325
Gerald Heikes 4,846
Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. 3,600

Peltola’s first-choice lead over the incumbent was 637 votes. Alaska’s News Source reported that the Associated Press had not called the race. Additional ballots remained outstanding; both leading campaigns argued that they were positioned to win. Those campaign assessments are not official results. 2

The Division of Elections labels the general-election results unofficial and says ranked-choice results will not be available until Nov. 18, once eligible ballots have been reviewed and counted. Its summary report contains first choices only. A cast vote record can show rankings on scanned ballots, but the division explicitly says that record is not a tabulation and excludes ballots counted only by hand. 4

Consequently, 3,600 is the reported first-choice count for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., not the number of all ballots ranking him anywhere. No official final round-by-round Senate result was available in the materials reviewed. A calculation using an incomplete set of scanned ballots must not be presented as the state’s final ranked-choice outcome.

Were the second Sullivan’s ballots set aside?

The published preliminary count includes votes for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. The Nov. 1 order did not grant DOJ’s request to segregate ballots ranking him. Nothing in that order transfers his votes to the incumbent. 1

If ranked-choice tabulation is necessary, voters’ own rankings govern transfers under Alaska’s rules. A vote for one Sullivan is not automatically a vote for the other. A ballot with no usable ranking for a continuing candidate can become inactive rather than transfer. 1 (pp. 5–6)4

This distinction matters: counting first choices, preserving election records and physically separating ballots for a proposed investigation are different actions. The sources reviewed establish inclusion in the preliminary count and the failure of DOJ’s segregation request—not a ballot-by-ballot audit of how every ranking has been handled.

The criminal inquiry is separate

On Oct. 30, U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman publicly confirmed a criminal investigation and a “significant surge of law enforcement assets to Alaska.” He did not identify the specific crimes being investigated and said he was not assuming a crime had occurred. 6

There is now named-source reporting of a subpoena. In a Nov. 6 CNN report, Senate candidate Gerald Heikes said FBI agents served him the previous Saturday. CNN reported reviewing the subpoena, which sought records involving campaigns, political groups and other people connected with the race. Heikes disputed that he was an operative; Peltola has denied knowing about efforts to recruit other candidates. DOJ declined to comment to CNN. A subpoena is not a criminal charge. 8

AP and CBS also reported target letters involving attorney Marc Elias and others, relying on unnamed sources. The details attributed solely to those sources remain unconfirmed by a publicly reviewed letter or named official here. Elias publicly criticized the investigation. Receiving a target letter does not establish guilt or mean an indictment will follow. No publicly announced criminal charge in this matter was identified in the sources reviewed through Nov. 6. 7

Why two Sullivans were on the ballot

The dispute began before the general election. Alaska’s election director disqualified Daniel J. Sullivan in June; the state superior court reversed that decision, and the Alaska Supreme Court affirmed on June 29. Gleason’s order recounts that history and explains that the general-election ballot used distinct names: “Sullivan, Dan S.” for the incumbent and “Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr.” for the challenger. The challenger’s ballot party line was blank. 1 (pp. 2–5)

That blank line does not merge the candidates or erase their different federal registrations. The FEC lists incumbent Dan Sullivan as S4AK00214 and challenger Daniel J Sullivan as S6AK00326. Both FEC records identify Republican Party affiliation; the ballot presentation is a separate issue. 10

The next meaningful election update is further counting and, if required, the official ranked-choice tabulation—not an assumption that the namesake candidate’s votes belong to someone else. Follow our Alaska Senate race page alongside the state’s results. Legal and investigative developments will be reported separately from the election outcome.